As was reported in Kaiju Shakedown, there has been lots of press coverage about "The Promise" environmental damage issues. In response to some frangmented articles that may give wrong impressions to international readers, "Chinabe Cinema", a Japanese language blog about Chinese movies, has put up a detailed account about what exactly happened, based on the reports on local newspapers. It is a little bit long, but I will try to translate everything here, for the sake of the fairness to the people involved in this movie. Before you join Chinese press's "The Promise" bashing band wagon, please take a moment to go through his chronicle.
Nov.03: "The Promise" production team decided to construct a large set in a lakeside location (I can't find the English spelling of the lake - something like "Pigutienchi") in Shangri-la Prefecture, Di Qing State, in Yun-nan Provice, accepting a strong sales push by Yunnan Provice government. Di Qing State accepted the project with a huge excitement, and organized a film commission within the government. The state government promised to provide help in many areas including procurement of the materials and the access road construction.
May 04: The set construction began. (The film production staff picked the construction company.)
June 8, 04: The film production staff arrived in Shangli-la. They started filming in other places other than the lake side. (There were 3 more locations within Shangri-la other than the lakeside.)
June 10, 04: The production staff examined the half-made set in the lakeside, and found cracks in the pillar.
June 12, 04: The production staff decided to stop the construction and not to film in the lakeside, due to the safety concerns.
June 14, 04: The staff/cast team moved to another location (Inner Mongolia), without making the final decision whether to come back to Shangri-la's lakeside location. It is reported that the production staff asked the local government to leave the set as is, as the evidence for the indemnity negotiation with the construction company. They eventually built another smaller set in Inner Mongolia, which made into the final film.
Aug. 05: The production staff informed Di Qing State government of their final decision not to use the set in Shangri-la lakeside, and they asked the government to tear down the set. As a compensation, they gave the government the rights to sell the construction material, and Di Qing State accepted the terms.
Aug-Oct. 05: Di Qing State gave Shanri-la Prefecture an order to tear down the set and sell the material. However, the severe winter weather prevented them to access the location, and they decided to wait till spring.
Dec. 05: "The Promise" opened in theaters in China.
Feb. 06: Local press picked up the issue.
Apr. 06: The snow melted and the major press finally had an access to the lakeside location, and started to write about it.
May 06: The production staff stated their official position, disclosing the documents they sent to the local government. They stated that the remains of the set is left there because of the weather and other factors, not because they abandoned it. The China federal government started the inquiry and passed a legislation to regulate the movie shooting in the scenic sights. The negotiations continue among the film crew, the local governments, and the construction company.
Mr. Chinabe points out the following 3 points to clarify the debate:
1. The lakeside location in the issue was not used for the filming at all, which means very few staff members and no cast were actually there.
2. Actually who littered the place is not clear.
3. It is a fact that the lakeside in Shanri-la was damaged, not so much by littering, but by leaving the construction material for more than 2 years there, and by building an access road for the construction.
He also stresses that the root of the problem is in the economic difficulties of the inner provinces such as Yunnan. They have no industry to speak of, so they are eager to attract movie production, in order to get free international tourism promotions.
Now that the Yunnan province could not get what they wanted, it is easy to see those disillusioned people start pointing fingers to everyone. In those situations, who would you go after? THE DEEP POCKET. (In case you missed this fact, "The Promise" was a huge hit in China.)
By reading this, it is not totally clear to me who IS actually responsible for taking away those materials and repair the damage - the local government (Province? State? Prefecture?), the construction company (the origin of the problem), or the film production team (so why were they undecided what to do with the set for a year, till way after the filming was over?).
Source: Chinabe Cinema
Recent Comments